Skip to main content
Should I make my 3 year old share his toys with his younger brother?

A: To answer this question we must first look at where your children are in their social and emotional development. Below is the development progression for sharing (you can find the entire development planning tool under the resource tab).  Since they are still at either exploring later or building earlier you shouldn't expect them to share at this time.

This is a time to teach them to ask if they want to play with each other's toys.  If the answer is no (which it usually is) then you will need to support your child when they become disappointed and upset that they cannot take a toy from their sibling.  I know this is very stressful for you as a parent, however, this is a critical stage of development.  You can model saying, "You really wanted his red car, I can tell you are upset."  Then gently find them a similar or duplicate toy.  You want your children to grow up respecting each other and the property of others.

A few things that worked for me was to buy duplicate "family" toys and teach children the difference between their personal toys and joint family toys.  Make sure to have two of them so they can play side by side without the expectation of sharing.  I had three girls in three years so I learned quickly to buy three of everything for special occasions.  Another idea is for you to model sharing items with your children to help them understand that it will be alright to share with people you love and trust.  Even with all of that said because of their age and development level they will likely not be able to share freely until they are both closer to 4 years old.  When they successfully grow through this stage, you will likely see them sharing toys for the rest of their lives. 


Popular posts from this blog

Association for Childhood Education International

ACEI 125 Years and Counting 1892-Present Committed to Innovation and Education for All Since the very beginning, ACEI has been an international organization driven by the belief that education is essential to human development. More than a century later, this core belief remains the same as we look at human development on a global scale and see how education has the power to change lives. Today, our commitment to advancing education translates to a commitment to education as a tool for global development and sustainable futures for all. ACEI works for the education of all children, but has a special interest in ensuring that our energies are focused on meeting the education needs of the most fragile and vulnerable children. ACEI’s work began in 1892, with the effort to promote kindergarten education in the United States and internationally. In the 1930s, we broadened our focus to progressive education and education through the primary sc

The Discontent Child

Child Discontentment: Children are born with discontentment.  Which means they are not satisfied.  Which shouldn't surprise us.  Children are safe in the womb, they are fed, sound is muffled and they are content.  Once born into this world feeding issues happen, bodily functions come into play, and sensory stimuli can be overwhelming (light, sounds and smells). Children need to have us help them through this process.  It is a type of conditioning of the mind.  Children need us adults to help them dwell on the earth with all of its wonders, distractions, and stimuli.   We need to support children in looking at the blessings of the earth (butterflies, smiles, flowers, gentle winds, loving voices, familiar faces, and cool summer nights) as well as showing expressions of gratitude for all that we have. What are you teaching children?